x

Moonshots


session 7: emergence

V

 
 

centering ideas

Emergence is subtle.
Emergence requires faith.
Emergence invites completion.

Can you emerge into yourself in a new way, starting with this session?
Can we drop the armor of the ego even more, and speak from the emergent heart of things?
What if this whole thing was beyond ideas, and was always hoping to lead back to the center of your center?

prework

#1: the invitation

“The ultimate achievement of reason is to recognize that there is an infinity of things which surpass it.”
Pascal

THE INVITATION IS THIS:
If you knew that our topsy turvy creation session created a doorway we could all walk through together, one where we all decide to drop the ego armor, drop the big word fancy footwork, drop the focus on definitions, and simply emerge into a new shared paradigm of being-ness and expression, would you do it?
Are you willing to lean in even further than you have thus far and use this container as a microcosm experiment in what that means for you?
What would change about how you show up, or not?

#2: cycles of completion

Consider the following emergence metaphors related to cycles of completion:.

  • Childbirth: in order to emerge, so much has to be let go. The baby must let go of the way s/he has previously learned to breathe, eat, and be. S/he must drop the connection to the mother through the umbilical cord. S/he must enter an entirely new environment. This all has to happen if the baby is to live their life.

  • Seed: in order to emerge it must leave the soil behind, let go of the cradle of the earth, and come into a different kind of communion with the world. It goes from being surrounded by darkness to being blinded by light. However if it were never to pop up out of the soil and leave behind the world it was nurtured by, it wouldn’t become the plant that it was always meant to be.

  • Snake Skin: Before the snake sheds its skin, the old skin lifts off. And the whole snake turns pale and discolored. And then when the skin comes off and the snake lets it go, you can see the vibrant colors that were always underneath the old grey layer! But you can’t see those vibrant colors if the snake doesn’t shed that skin, and emerge out of it. Also, sub metaphor: the longer you deny that next layer of skin underneath, the more pale/muted you become. 

Then.

Drop in. Listen to your gut, your instinct, your intuition, your emotions…and trust whatever comes up first, no matter how abstract or specific. Your answers can be informed by the program experience thus far, or by wider circles of your life. Naming cycles of completion allows for an arising energy into what’s next, or even what’s now.
What does your emergent self include? Can you name that?
And what does it not include? Can you name that?

Bonus

What do you need to complete in order to emerge?
Where are you feeling hung up, angry, apathetic, resentful, or stuck?
If those dynamics no longer serve you, can you give yourself the gift of releasing this right now?
What piece of your past are you still choosing to drag into your present (that isn’t helpful, or that is expired)?
What would it require of you to simply decide complete that cycle right now?
What is most stopping you from completing these cycles?
If you did choose to complete something in order to more fully emerge, what difference would that make for you?
What difference would that make in terms of what you’d be able to step out of - and therefore into - as a result?

post-work

#1: sawubona

Sawubona is an African greeting that translates to “I see you” but that is also an invitation to actively drop into a deeper presence of witnessing throughout the interaction. Sawubona wisdom says that being truly witnessed is essential to human freedom. What are your thoughts on this? What elements of this have you seen or experienced inside this container, or in your life? What changes when you are available to be seen within your Emergence, or when you drop in to a moment in a way that allows you to see another? What are the parallels between this and innovation, leadership, and building a world we believe in?

#2: courage

As we discussed in session, courage is an act of the heart, ideally rooted deep in meaningful alignment. It takes courage to be still enough to hear what’s meant for us, and it takes courage to step into action. How can these elements of courage co-exist, or do they? What does courage mean for you, and what does it take? Where is one area of your life you an commit to one courageous action this week?

#3: curiosity

Presence and curiosity leads to very real magic. If you can cultivate curiosity, your life will have deep meaning. Where in your life can you be more curious in order to emerge into a new self, a new possibility? Where in your life can you be more curious to allow something else to unexpectedly emerge from perceived stagnancy?

#4: Moonshot v.0.crap

What is the object from the future (or from the future “you”) that is emerging in you or through you right now? How does it look like? What if it would be a song, a poem, a paing, an abstract object? Paint it, say it, sketch it, name it!

Try to brainstorm about your moonshots ideas in the form of:

How might we help … (put a person/community/entity/nature here), in a world where … (put a constraint here). 

For instance: 

  • How might we help to preserve biodiversity in a world where continual development is the pathway to success?

  • How might we help teenagers taken agency of their lives, in a world where popularity is the new cool

If you need help envisioning your v.0.crap moonshot ideas or dream about new worlds, please reach out to me (Pablo) for the world building framework.

session recording

Session recording and transcript!

session readings

Opening Reading

The journey
of human becoming
is mystifying
complex
dimensional
exhilarating.
Learning
to understand
and receive
the hidden gifts of life
that can be unwrapped
in so many infinite ways
is my current job description.
It's up to me
to choose
to See.
It's up to me
to look at something
or someone
long enough
to witness the teachings
the wisdom
the interconnectedness.
Even if
at first
it appears to be
an inconvenience
an impenetrable wall
or something I'd rather not experience.
Everything, everything
moves with and within all of us
like a cosmic hall of mirrors.
Nothing is certain -
in fact
certainty of anything
indicates
a lack of looking
for long enough
to witness the mystery
in all things.
And the delight
of discovery
is the whole point.
To be fully engaged with life
is to know
that nothing is certain
and that everything
is fundamentally
in motion.
Evolving, changing, rearranging.
And that no matter what
even in the impossibility
even in the bliss
even in the devastation
even in the mess
even in the piercing spotlight
there is harmonious discord
to be grasped
and revealed
and sung about.

Christine Owenell

Closing Reading

The Unbroken

There is a brokenness
out of which comes the unbroken,
a shatteredness
out of which blooms the unshatterable.
There is a sorrow
beyond all grief which leads to joy
and a fragility
out of whose depths emerges strength.

There is a hollow space
too vast for words
through which we pass with each loss,
out of whose darkness
we are sanctioned into being.

There is a cry deeper than all sound
whose serrated edges cut the heart
as we break open to the place inside
which is unbreakable and whole,
while learning to sing.

Rashani Réa




 

content highlights

(((moonshots)))

Patience/Impatience

Innovation is a delicate thing. It needs just the right mix of serendipitous discovery and structure. There’s no step-by-step manual for striking this balance, but there are some mindsets and habits that will help improve your odds.

Moonshots need to have the patience to let difficult solutions unravel and the impatience to undertaken them as quickly as you can.

Experimenting and learning quickly is paramount. Make sure your teams know how to set up great experiments where they can derisk loads of important unknowns with little costs. Even if the results are negative, this is great if you learn them fast. Focus on the experiment, not the result. The only real failure is that of not learning anything.
Prototype early and deliver intermediate proof points. Don’t think too big for your intermediate experiments, in fact think small. If you take a small risk and fail, who cares. 
Take the minimum effort to learn the most and do it super cheap. Create quick objects from the future, videos with explorations of ideas, paper prototypes, and achieve intermediate moonshot milestones — which could even be self-sustained small(er)-businesses, before eventually turning into a full-blown moonshot impact.
Spend a couple of days prototyping something very rough. If it goes nowhere, no one will care. But if it’s interesting, you make the next prototype. Maybe a week’s work. And then you move on and on from there.

Emergence calls for Initiative

Just get going
There’s no instruction manual for moonshots; we roll up our sleeves and take the initiative to figure out a way. Grab a shovel and start digging.

Learn to love “version 0.crap”
Don’t let perfect be the enemy of good. It’s more important to get going than sit around thinking about the perfect outcome. It’s okay to share early drafts and fragments of emerging thoughts, so others can also help.

Brutal Honesty/Authenticity
Go for impact, not intellectual wandering. You need to keep yourself intellectually honest, with rigor, and be dispassionate about trying to find the reasons why the moonshot will fail and tackle them first. De-risk, and learn super fast.

Proactive prototyping

What if everyone has the potential to do things that are inside them, but they never act on it? In fact, we all probably have a moonshot inside us. And many of us die with that moonshot because we refuse to act. 

No fantazise, act on it. Creative Futures is not in the realm of theoretical imagination. It is very much about f creating (and recovering) blueprints for action. Prototyping and the emergence of “provisionally specific” artifacts is a very powerful creative tool. Prototyping is a catch-all term for rapidly something emerge to see if it works, if it sticks with you and others, but a good prototype also offers a secondary function. It helps a group of people move beyond conversations and loose ideas by creating an embodied thing. It brings people together behind a single articulation of what might otherwise be a broad range of possibilities. It encourages detailed discussion as opposed to abstract opinions. We use prototypes in Moonshots to express where we think something might be going, without being sure. We also call it provisional specificity.

Many times during a project we reach a point where we can’t be exact about something, there are just too many unknowns, it feels like there’s no clear path forward and this can be paralyzing. Instead you put ‘something’ there, let something emerge, our best guess, just for now. Let’s be provisionally specific, about the creation. This is a way of emerging. 
This can be a model of something, an object from the future, a new way of seeing things, a poem, an image, a song, a piece of software which appears to work. It can be focused on a tiny detail or the big vision, but expressing the emergence of something that has been created through us, in us — anything — can almost always accelerate thinking, help make decisions, uncover blindspots and bring teams together.

In truth, emergence is messy. It follows no clean path, and doesn’t flow naturally from one step to the next. 

Speculative Design prototypes often look and feel like the prototypes I described earlier, but they don’t exist as statements of ‘things-to-be-made’; they exist to provoke you and others, as a means to facilitate conversations, to pre-visualize issues and impact. Bringing people together through the story of the dream(more here

Unintended consequences

The creations, either the creation of ourselves, the new iteration of an idea or a moonshot, or whatever we are creating and bringing into the world, have been buried or in an incubation mode or in the tunnel before they are brought to life.
And where those ideas meet the world of light and air and fulfillment, are not always just like this glory moment. It can feel really overwhelming and has unexpected consequences.

The power of Emerging a v.0.crap is that it also allows us to tackle not just positive, but neutral and negative outcomes of our creations. To think through the potential impacts — positive and negative — of the creative work. 

By speculating on the impact of these interventions, we’re able to think beyond the ‘perfect’ solution, to discuss externalities, to consider people who might be averse to the idea or whose livelihoods may be negatively affected. 

By producing prototypes of these events (a newspaper headline, a protest poster, a poem) we are able to explore and iterate fast.

It’s not a perfect or foolproof approach, and there will be countless unseen blindspots in any project, but producing these emerging prototypes forces awkward conversations to become tangible, unavoidable and focused.

Knowledge Hub Emergence

Emerging and solving the gap from believe to impact, requires building Communities where you can engage with the community of experts, misfits, social entrepreneurs, doers and kindred spirits  for the whole duration of the moonshot. People who build an atmosphere of gratitude. I believe the reason why some of the work we are doing here could be so impactful, is because we are all doing our own work in the midst of being in community. We are building the fabric of ourselves and of a moonshot concept in the midst of this group container.

When it comes to letting go of what no longer is aligned or letting go of what no longer serves you, showing gratitude is essential. It is super important to do this work, finding the next moonshot idea in groups of diverse human beings where gratitude can be expressed as you navigate chaos.




content highlights

(((alchemy of chaos)))

Emergence, Entropy, & Abiogenesis

There is an entire science of the origin of life embedded into the notion of Emergence. There is a whole connection between the origin of life (out of the primordial soup of chaos, no less) which is apparently called abiogenesis, and entropy, and emergence. In order for life to spontaneously emerge from the primordial soup, there is a perpetual influx of energy…and not just an influx of energy, but the understanding that systems will attempt spread energy out (in the form of light, heat, etc) in order to disperse it. In order to disperse energy efficiently, that is when the beginnings of RNA and DNA form. So matter has this imperitive to self-organize in an effort to better disperse energy. And nature, in an effort to promote disorder and chaotic tendencies aimed at dispersing energy (like a tornado, or a lightening bolt), ends up creating...wait for it...order. Pockets of order. It is these pockets of order that are structures that escalate the chaos of a system, and thereby create entropy, which is the necessity of things falling apart. A thundercloud collecting energy and reaching capacity then organizes itself into a bolt of lightning to disperse the built up energy into the earth - a moment of chaos which results in a rebalancing of the ecosystem. And Pablo mentioned how curiosity diffuses the energy. Curiosity is a lightning bolt. Truth is a lightning bolt.

So, just to be clear, the building blocks of our very existence (literally!) is in the truth that chaos = energy influx = dispersing energy = entropy = emergent order. As it turns out, non-life can’t work with energy, and life is an exceptionally efficient tool for rebalancing chaos. There’s a cool connection point between this and Activation…but we will get to that on Saturday.

Surprise

An emergent world invites us to be alert in the moment for what is unfolding. Emergence is an interesting state - it is a place where the creations that have been buried or in incubation mode meet the world of light and air and fulfillment, so what I am interested in is highlighting the importance of cultivating the ability or environment to be surprised, as well as acknowledging cycles of completion in order for emergence to happen. Usually if we are not in a habit of naming cycles of completion, what tends to happen is that we are more likely to bring old patterns and old habits and old behaviors and old karma into our next iterations of ourselves, into what we are creating anew. In my experience, dragging the past into the present really colors the way we are able to show up and limits our possibilities. Being consciously aligned with emergence requires presence, awareness, and being vigilant for the newly visible. We need to notice things we weren’t looking for, things we didn’t know would be important, influences we hadn’t thought of, behaviors we couldn’t predict.

The Third Great Shaking

A friend’s mentor said that she spoke with a Hopi elder who called this pandemic time the Third Great Shaking in the history of humanity, and that it is a powerful time for awakening. The elder said the COVID-19 world is a cocoon time. A forced stillness, an inner winter. And she shared that the DNA that comes into play which allows the caterpillar to turn into a butterfly is the same DNA that comes into play when a virus moves through the body. So we are literally and metaphorically in a DNA-altering cocoon time. We are changing, becoming, and morphing. And becoming doesn’t always look as we expect it to, like in the case of the one-winged butterfly…but a lesson we have learned separately and together is that the struggle is what allows the unfurling of the wings to happen, and that to attempt to mitigate that struggle could paralyze someone’s ability to fly. As Salome pointed out: “Do not steal someone’s struggle from them, or you take away their power.” There is something about emergence, becoming, expressing, flying…all wrapped around struggle and expectation and death and life and regeneration. 

Facing Ourselves, Facing Each Other

Emergence is not as much about emerging into someplace new, as it is about emerging into a new piece of your own self. Emerging into a new world that already exists within. So much of the work I continue to come back around to is the importance of being able to become aware of the expanded perspectives of ourselves that exist within. The journey inward is an infinite journey. There are multiverses inside. It’s like seeing the human soul as an onion, and with inquiry and experience achieved through mirrors and flashlights, you peel off those layers. But as you move inwards, the layers/veils get thinner and more numerous, to the extent that you would never be able to “achieve” or “arrive” or “accomplish” the discovery of yourself. There is no center to the human soul. 

Something that I think is a stumbling block on the trajectory of this deeper level awareness work with what “emergence” means is a belief that there is a place to arrive in the midst of this work, that once you emerge, you’re done. Update: there is no arrival. There is emergence, but only to emerge again and again. If there is an arrival point, it is in the understanding that there is actually not an arrival. By fully participating in our lives, we continue to become, and as we become, there are new aspects of ourselves that are born and that come into focus, and as we get curious about those new aspects, we face ourselves in new ways, and as we face ourselves in new ways, we face each other.

Emergency

We have framed "emergency” as something to be avoided, as something we don’t want. My deeper hypothesis is that it goes back to our discomfort with change - or as was mentioned in session, movement - in general. But we can choose to see this word emergency in a new way. An emergency is a situation that was unexpected, and something new or different is emerging from what we perceived to be a stable situation...or at least our perception of it was stable. 

Another thing that is interesting about an emergency is that our full attention tends to go towards whatever the emergency is. This is also something to note because I do think for our purposes, Emergence does require our conscious acknowledgement and attention. So an emergency claims our attention, so that we can be with this new something. But so often we are attempting to mitigate the emergency. 

What if we practiced seeing emergencies as a necessary (albeit usually unwelcome) shift? How would that change our behaviors, beliefs, and beingness? 

Emergence is happening all the time. What makes the difference between a 5 alarm emergency which we defend ourselves, our stability, our loved ones, from, and an emergent new reality which we more gracefully usher in?

Dissonance

We create limits to remember that we are limitless. Transformation, therefore, is an expansion beyond what we previously thought was perhaps impossible. To expand to this place, I must un-become the version of me that is still fixated on an old limit. That limit serves me because it is in facing it that I have the opportunity to move beyond it. The outside world isn’t known for responding well to us emerging into different iterations of ourselves, because just like we avoid dissonance in ourselves, we reject dissonance in others. And just like we discussed in session, we also tend to reject struggle. It almost comes back down to supporting everyone else around us to do the work to recognize and experience the value and gift in dissonance. I believe the reason the work we have done here has been so impactful, and why this group feels safe, is because we are all doing our own work in the midst of being in community. We are weaving the fabric of ourselves in the midst of this group container serving as the loom. Without the loom, it’s harder to weave. When it comes to letting go of what no longer is aligned or letting go of what no longer serves you, showing gratitude is essential. This is because whatever you’re letting go of has played an integral role in your life, and without the process of that you wouldn’t become who you are. What you gain from navigating the dissonance is just as much a part of who you become.  

Releasing the Bow. Diving In.

“A property of a system is said to be emergent if it is a new outcome of some other properties of the system and their interaction, while it is itself different from them.” That is exactly what we are doing here.

Emergence refers to the existence or formation of collective behaviors, acknowledging what parts of a system do together that they would not or could not do alone. This makes me think of Alchemy. In describing collective behaviors, emergence refers to how collective properties arise from the properties of parts, how behavior at a larger scale arises from the detailed structure, behavior, and relationships at a finer scale. So Emergence is spotting patterns by seeing the details and the big picture at the same time, as well as understanding the relationships among the parts themselves AND the relationship of parts to their environment. When we think about Emergence we are, in our mind's eye, moving among views at different scales. We see the trees and the forest at the same time, in order to see how the trees and the forest are related to each other.

The whole program thus far has been pulling back the arrow farther and farther, each week, diving deeper, unearthing more, naming multitudes...in order to arrive at activation and release. Release our emergent selves and emergent perspectives into the world in order to activate new possibilities. Of course, I like to also picture that when doing this level of work, you’re swimming in water, and with each new insight, a new movement happens, which creates a new ripple that you send out, however subtly. So many of you have been sharing with me in sidebar conversations some very real shifts that you are seeing in your world in the past 7 weeks. It’s not a coincidence. When you dive into these waters, shift happens. The deciding to dive part is where the initial magic is...and to acknowledge that you arrived at the place where you even are considering the decision to dive...that is also such real and true work. And then the diving. And the moving. And the ripple creating. And then the emerging onto new land. And then the seeing of new things. And then the coming back to the decision to dive back into the water, from a new place, perhaps from a different height, as a new self. And on and on it goes. Life is death. Death is life. The struggle eventuates in the liberation of freefall, the realization that you will land, and it might sting, but you will already be off swimming and rippling in this newest iteration of discovery of yourself within the context of your life. You will continue to release more arrows into the world of your life, for as long as you dare to keep creating tension in the bow. 


 

Session Highlights

The invitation for you

is to become an alchemist.

Step into the possibility
that awaits you
beyond strategy,
beyond the mental monkey mind,
beyond forecasts,
and beyond what is “known.”

Understand that alchemy
happens in the process
and is not found
in the outcome.

Everything is always in a state of flux
and it is within that state of flux
that transformation and innovation take place.

 
 

Of course, alchemy is a mirror unto itself. Your quest to access your inner alchemist is the alchemical process required to then alchemize everything around you.

 
 
 

Turn the lead into gold.

Turn the poison into nectar.

Turn the impossibility into liberation.

 
 

About Christine Owenell
creator of Alchemy of Chaos

about pablo rodriguez
purveyor of moonshots

Uncover